DOJ Sets New Rules on Preliminary Investigations and Inquest Proceedings
The Department of Justice (DOJ) issued the 2024 Department of Justice-National Prosecution Service (DOJ-NPS) Rules on Preliminary Investigations and Inquest Proceeding through Department Circular No. 015 dated July 16, 2024.
The DOJ-NPS rules shall govern the conduct of preliminary investigations and inquest proceedings in all prosecution offices in the National Prosecution Service (NPS) of the DOJ.
As provided in the repealing clause of the DOJ-NPS rules, its adoption warrants the repeal of affected provisions of Rule 112 on Preliminary Investigation of the 2000 Revised Rules on Criminal Procedure and other inconsistent rules and orders. Additionally, the new rules provide that the Rules of Court shall apply in suppletory character whenever practicable.
This is pursuant to the ruling of the Supreme Court En Banc in a resolution written by Associate Justice Rodil Zalameda which recognized the authority of the DOJ to promulgate its own rules on preliminary investigation.
The Supreme Court emphasized that the power to conduct of preliminary investigation, which is inquisitorial in nature, is lodged with the prosecutor, and thus, a function of the executive department, not the judiciary.
The following are the notable provisions under the new rules:
- Coverage
The conduct of a preliminary investigation shall be required for crime and offenses where the penalty prescribed by law is at least six (6) years and one (1) day without regard to fine.
- Quantum of Evidence
The evidentiary standard in preliminary investigation and inquest proceedings has changed from “probable cause” to a stricter threshold of “reasonable certainty of conviction”. This quantum exists when “a prima facie case is established by the evidence-at-hand including but not limited to testimonial evidence, documentary evidence, and real evidence; and such evidence, on its own and if left uncontroverted by the accused, shall be sufficient to establish all the elements of the crime or offense charged, and consequently warrant a conviction beyond reasonable doubt”.
- NPS Investigation Data Form (IDF)
The original complaint-affidavit shall be accompanied by a duly accomplished NPS Investigation Data Form.
- Virtual preliminary investigation, e-inquest proceedings, and e-filing
Adoption of procedures for e-filing, as well as the conduct of virtual preliminary investigation hearings and e-inquest proceedings, as alternatives, are now institutionalized under the new rules.
Virtual preliminary investigation is conducted through videoconferencing and may be availed at the initial hearing where both parties are present and the information and communications technology (ICT) is available to both the prosecution office and the parties. Clarificatory hearings may also be conducted virtually. All videoconference hearings shall be recorded.
Filing or service of the counter-affidavit, in case an extension is allowed, or when deemed necessary, of reply-affidavit or rejoinder-affidavit, shall be made electronically in Portable Document Format (PDF)and sent via electronic mail (email). Electronic copies of affidavits or of any document not in PDF, or in PDF but not legible, or are protected by a password or other encryption, or with embedded executable code or scripts, or otherwise corrupted, shall not be considered as having been filed and therefore excluded from the records of the case.
E-inquest is the conduct of inquest through videoconferencing, which may be availed by the inquest prosecutor, on his or her own initiative or upon request of the referring law enforcement agency or concerned private citizen, provided both the prosecution office and the parties have access to ICT.
It must be noted that only the Supreme Court could repeal the Rules of Court, including the rules on criminal procedure, following its constitutional grant of power to exclusively promulgate rules on pleading, practice, and procedure in all courts.
The Supreme Court will not interfere with the DOJ’s prerogative to direct and control the conduct of preliminary investigations as long as there is no grave abuse of discretion.
This is without prejudice to the Court’s promulgation of a new rule on preliminary investigation consistent with the DOJ-NPS Rules.
In line with this, the Supreme Court has organized the Proposed Amendments to the Rules on Criminal Procedure Regional Consultations which aims to engage various stakeholders in discussing proposed amendments to the Rules on Criminal Procedure in recognition of the DOJ-NPS Rules. Interested participants for the first leg of the Consultations, which will be held on August 8, 2024 at the De La Salle Lipa in Lipa City, Batangas, may register through this link.
The full text of the DOJ-NPS rules can be read here.